From Policy Updates to Ethical Dilemmas: Universities' Response to Artificial Intelligence in Education

2023-07-11

"Universities are grappling with the ethical and pedagogical implications of generative artificial intelligence (AI). Last week, the Russell Group of universities in the UK, including Oxford and Cambridge, updated their policies on the use of AI in education. Harvard University, an Ivy League institution, has gone a step further by 'employing' AI chatbots like ChatGPT to teach their flagship course, Computer Science 50 (CS50). On the other hand, Bangalore University, RV University, and other universities in the city have banned the use of AI by students. Professors must establish guidelines on the ethical use of AI, but there are currently no definitive answers to this issue. Challenges arise when it comes to determining whether specific content is generated by AI or created by students. Turnitin, an anti-plagiarism software, has updated its functionality to detect whether assignments are generated by AI, and is now widely used by professors. Professors face the risk of mistaking original works for those written by ChatGPT, and are unable to determine how much of each assignment is original or how students are using generative AI. As this is not always reliable, teachers are turning to methods such as oral exams, multiple-choice questions, and even automated grading systems being tested in schools and universities in Singapore and the United Arab Emirates. However, these methods are time-consuming. An alternative approach to incorporating AI into universities is to prohibit its use. But how can this be regulated? It is easy to deceive Turnitin by editing AI-generated works. Sometimes, works generated by generative AI are even better and can easily pass as original after some real relevance checks. Ethical approaches include increasing students' understanding of AI, teaching them the necessary skills for using AI responsibly, including concepts of privacy, biases in generative AI, inaccuracies, and plagiarism. The statement further states that "adaptation of teaching and assessment methods will vary across universities and disciplines, and protecting this autonomy is crucial." Universities have already started offering multiple courses on the responsible use of AI for students. Jill Walker Rettberg, a professor of digital culture and co-director of the new Center for Excellence in Digital Narrative, said, "We recently offered a small course worth 2.5 European credits, designed to be accessible to all students. Some are online courses, and some are taught on campus. They are very small, so any student can participate." These courses have reportedly been "very popular," with hundreds of students enrolling in each course, and are now open to faculty and external individuals as well. She added, "As a university, it is important to ensure that our students and faculty have a basic understanding of how to use AI responsibly and constructively." Furthermore, several papers are being written on the application of AI in schools and the responsible use of AI in scientific writing. Universities are striving to find solutions that not only address who is cheating using technology but also understand how to use it more effectively for teaching, and change curricula to adapt to the skills required in this new job landscape. White-collar jobs are evolving alongside this technology, making it crucial to equip the future workforce with the ability to effectively use AI. Some universities are taking a cautious approach by banning the use of AI tools. If students are suspected of cheating, they will undergo random checks and oral exams. Other universities and schools encourage the use of AI but with certain guidelines. Thomas Jørgensen, Director of Policy Coordination and Forward Planning at the European University Association (EUA), said, "Universities should not only focus on ChatGPT but also on how AI is being applied more broadly. Universities and the academic community are carefully considering the consequences of using new technologies, and the importance of critical dialogue continues to emerge." Source: https://analyticsindiamag.com/universities-grapple-with-ai-in-education/"

RECENT AI NEWS

RECENT AI TOOLS