OpenAI Faces Another Class Action Lawsuit

2023-06-30

A new case has been filed in a federal court in Northern California, aiming to test a novel legal theory that claims OpenAI has infringed the rights of millions of internet users. A prominent law firm based in California has filed a class-action lawsuit against OpenAI. The lawsuit alleges that OpenAI has extensively violated the copyrights and privacy rights of numerous individuals by using data scraped from the internet to train its technology. This is not the first time. Previously, Anthony Trupia filed a lawsuit claiming that OpenAI has been operating a "non-profit" entity purportedly for the benefit of all humanity but has engaged in massive fraud against donors, beneficiaries, and the public, putting "all of humanity" at significant risk. In November last year, Microsoft, OpenAI, and GitHub were hit with a collective lawsuit accusing them of unauthorized scraping of licensed code while building the AI-powered Copilot. This has turned into a nightmare for them, and the problem is getting worse. They are now desperately seeking a way out and requesting the court to dismiss the collective lawsuit. During a hearing in the US Senate, Sam Altman, the CEO of OpenAI, mentioned that OpenAI has been sued multiple times before. When asked by Senator Lindsey Graham about the reasons for the lawsuits, Altman replied, "Well, I mean, they're mostly kind of boring things that I think any company would get sued for," without providing further details. This time it's for real. Previously, AIM predicted that OpenAI might encounter more legal issues. However, the latest case filed in a federal court in Northern California is just one of them. This case aims to test a novel legal theory that claims OpenAI has infringed the rights of millions of internet users by using their social media comments, blog posts, Wikipedia articles, and even family recipes. The law firm Clarkson, specializing in various large-scale class-action lawsuits, including data breaches and false advertising, has filed the lawsuit. Ryan Clarkson, the managing partner of the law firm, stated that their intention is to represent the "real people" whose information was illegally obtained and used to develop this highly influential technology. OpenAI has not yet responded to requests for comments on this lawsuit. This legal lawsuit addresses an important unresolved issue related to the widespread use of "generative" AI tools such as chatbots and image generators. These technologies process vast amounts of textual data from the internet and learn to establish connections between them. Through extensive data input, these "large language models" gain the ability to predict appropriate responses, enabling them to engage in complex conversations, write poetry, and even pass professional exams. However, the individuals who originally created these billions of words have never authorized companies like OpenAI to use their data for profit. Clarkson believes, "All this information was obtained on a massive scale, and it was not intended for large language models." He expressed hope that this lawsuit will lead to the establishment of guidelines for training AI algorithms and provide fair compensation for individuals whose data is used. The law firm has organized a group of plaintiffs and actively seeks others to join this lawsuit. The legality of using scraped data from the publicly available internet to train profitable AI tools remains uncertain. Some AI developers argue that using internet data falls under the "fair use" category in copyright law, allowing exceptions if the material has undergone significant transformation. Katherine Gardner, an intellectual property lawyer from Gunderson Dettmer, representing major tech startups, stated that artists and other creators whose copyrighted works have been used to train AI models could potentially sue companies. However, it is challenging for individuals who have only posted or commented on websites to successfully claim damages. The new collective lawsuit against OpenAI expands the scope of its accusations, claiming that the company lacks sufficient transparency when notifying users that their tools may be used to train new products that can be commercialized, such as their Plugins tool. Additionally, the lawsuit alleges that OpenAI has not taken adequate measures to prevent children under the age of 13 from using their tools, a concern previously raised against other tech companies like Facebook and YouTube. This lawsuit further adds to the growing list of legal challenges faced by companies involved in the development of AI technologies and their potential profitability. In February of this year, image supplier Getty Images also filed a lawsuit against AI startup Stability AI, accusing the company of illegally using Getty's photos to train its image-generating robots. Additionally, OpenAI recently faced a defamation lawsuit from a radio host in Georgia who claimed that text generated by ChatGPT falsely accused him of fraud. Although OpenAI is not the only company using scraped data from the internet to train its AI models, this law firm chose to sue OpenAI because ChatGPT gained public attention last year, prompting larger competitors to develop their own AI technologies. The proposed regulations under discussion aim to require companies to be more transparent about the data they use in their AI models. According to Gardner, the court cases may also force companies like OpenAI to disclose information about the data they use. Some companies are attempting to prevent AI companies from scraping their data. According to the Financial Times, music distributor Universal Music Group requested Apple and Spotify to block data scraping in April this year. Social media website Reddit demanded payment for access to more content after ceasing data access, citing that large tech companies have been scraping comments and conversations from their website for years. Elon Musk threatened to sue Microsoft, accusing them of using data obtained from Twitter to train their AI. Musk is building his own AI company. Source: https://analyticsindiamag.com/openai-gets-slapped-with-another-class-action-lawsuit/

RECENT AI NEWS

RECENT AI TOOLS