Call for Suspension of Facial Recognition Highlights the Necessity of Preventing Surveillance Technology

2020-02-01

The debate over whether to ban or suspend the use of facial recognition began last year in cities like San Francisco, but this week, Alphabet and Google CEO Sundar Pichai reignited the controversy by expressing his openness to a temporary suspension of facial recognition.


Pichai said, "Facial recognition regulation can have an immediate impact, but perhaps we need to wait for some time to truly consider its usage." He expressed support for the five-year moratorium being considered by the European Commission in Brussels. Later this week, at the World Economic Forum in Davos, he voiced his support for regulation of artificial intelligence while emphasizing the need for AI to evolve through practice.



On the other hand, Microsoft seems to be less inclined to delay the use of facial recognition. Microsoft's President and Chief Legal Officer, Brad Smith, pointed out some positive use cases, such as finding missing children, and argued that bans and suspensions could hinder progress. He said, "Ultimately, there is only one way to make technology better, and that is to use it."


Last year, Microsoft also rejected proposals for a suspension in its home state of Washington. Unlike Google, Microsoft and Amazon are actively selling facial recognition services to businesses and governments. With these tech giants legalizing the sale and deployment of facial recognition software in their home state of Washington and globally, about a dozen states are considering enacting facial recognition regulations.


It is important to note that facial recognition is becoming an emerging industry, with some of the world's most well-funded AI startups involved. The entire AI industry is experiencing significant growth. CB Insights and the National Venture Capital Association found that AI startups raised record-breaking funding in the US and globally in 2019. The AI Index 2019 analysis revealed that AI business investments exceeded $70 billion last year, with facial recognition ranking high in the investment field. Companies are exploring use cases for AI ranging from patient or employee verification to analyzing job applicants in video interviews, but another call for suspension this week highlighted its use in surveillance.


In May 2018, following an investigation into the hacking of Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos' iPhone X, the United Nations called for a global suspension of private surveillance technology. Ironically, Jeff Bezos' company sells facial recognition.


We have an example here of the richest person on Earth, who has unlimited resources, taking months to realize his phone was hacked, and top experts took three months to trace the source of the hack. So, this technology is dangerous for everyone. It poses a threat to US national security and democratic processes."


Earlier this week, an op-ed in The New York Times emphasized the point that focusing on banning or suspending facial recognition overlooks a more important issue: the operation of digital data brokerage companies with almost no regulation today, and true transformation requires comprehensive privacy regulation.


In the debate over how to regulate facial recognition, one can almost always find arguments that regulation stifles innovation, but limiting the use of this technology in public spaces does not necessarily stifle innovation. That is a hasty argument. Using the technology in a laboratory or limited environment can still promote technological advancements.


People can choose to delay a technology, but that does not mean there won't be consequences. But one also needs to ask the question: How will commerce and society become worse if facial recognition usage is not restricted?


While some facial recognition systems have made progress in performance, analysis from the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) shows that bias still exists.



Microsoft was one of the first to call for regulation of facial recognition software back in the summer of 2018.


The recent statements by Smith and Pichai about the need to use technology to make it better seem to suggest that society must adapt to technology, rather than the other way around. However, there are still many unanswered questions and lack of regulation regarding the application of facial recognition or surveillance technology in today's society. The idea of a suspension must be put on the table, as it allows time for regulation, standards, and testing results, while also protecting individuals from surveillance and potential infringements on their rights.


Action is necessary to prevent the proliferation of private surveillance, as actions in facial recognition are moving rapidly now, both for legislators eager to take action and for companies interested in deploying or selling the technology.


But if we lose the ability to protect citizens from private surveillance in the pursuit of innovation, then we will lose even more in the so-called AI arms race.

RECENT AI NEWS

RECENT AI TOOLS