Today's HR interviewer is really tough!

2019-11-20

The peak of acting skills for office workers is often dedicated to various forms of scapegoating or dealing with interviewers. However, it is not so easy to pass the interview stage by relying on "establishing a personal image". Since the popularity of artificial intelligence, many companies have handed over the baton of interviews to AI, which has put a stranglehold on the fate of job seekers who have gone through countless "interview guides". AI interviewers are even more terrifying than human interviewers. They not only screen resumes but also decide whether you can pass the interview based on your appearance. Most importantly, they have no emotions. According to The Washington Post, many Fortune 500 companies, including Unilever, L'Oreal, Coca-Cola, and Goldman Sachs, have started using artificial intelligence for interviews. More than one million job seekers worldwide have experienced AI interviews, and some universities even offer training courses to help students perform better in AI interviews. AI can recognize the most suitable candidates based on more than 15,000 features, including candidates' language vocabulary, eye movements, speed of answering questions, and volume of voice. As early as March 2017, in an industry competition organized by a well-known North American headhunting company, a machine called "Brilent" took only 3.2 seconds to select suitable candidates. Among all the providers of enterprise AI interview services, the most well-known is probably HireVue. According to their official website, more than 700 companies worldwide use their video interview system, and their clients include Oracle and Intel. HireVue's interview process is as follows: 1. Receive interview invitation from the company and log in to HireVue. 2. Sit in front of a computer or phone camera and answer preset questions. It is best to dress professionally and pay attention to every detail, showing excellence. During the interview, it is important to remain calm. For example, if a question appears on the screen that is not within our preparation range, we need to maintain steady eye contact, avoid facial twitching, show no signs of nervousness, control voice tremors, and answer confidently with a rehearsed professional smile. 3. A standard HireVue interview lasts for 30 minutes and includes 6 questions. After completing all the sections, the job seeker can finish recording and upload the video. HireVue will review the uploaded video, capturing the interviewee's facial expressions, body language, tone, and even blinking movements, generating 500,000 data points. Then, artificial intelligence and IT algorithms are used for analysis to help companies screen candidates. 4. What's more impressive is that HireVue's predictive algorithm can even calculate the probability of the interviewee leaving the company in the future. HireVue's spokesperson said, "Except for extreme scores, we use artificial intelligence to determine the performance of interviewees." For campus recruitment, HireVue can significantly improve recruitment efficiency, allowing HR to review more candidates in a shorter period of time and select the best talents for further evaluation. Hilton's data shows that with the help of HireVue, the recruitment cycle has been reduced from 20 days to 4.5 days. The process of HireVue is as follows: 1. Receive interview email and confirm the interview time within 48 hours. 2. Use a computer or download the HireVue app on a mobile phone for the interview. 3. The interview starts with watching pre-recorded question videos. 4. There is about 30 seconds for preparation, and then 1.5-3 minutes for recording, depending on the question. There is a countdown reminder on the screen. (Some companies allow "re-recording" if the interviewee is not satisfied with their performance after watching the playback.) 5. A foreign student shared his HireVue interview experience. He encountered a written question at Goldman Sachs, where he needed to write an email to a client. 6. In a HireVue interview at Goldman Sachs, you will be asked 5-6 questions, with 80% being behavioral questions and 20% specific to the department. You have 30 seconds to prepare for each answer and two minutes to speak to the camera, with no second chance. The entire process takes about 15 minutes. 7. Finally, the AI system generates an evaluation report on the interviewee, including indicators such as "personal stability," "willingness to learn," and "problem-solving ability." 8. Based on the job requirements, the AI interviewer will classify the candidates into high, medium, and low levels. Although employers can still choose to focus on candidates with lower rankings, companies that have chosen AI interviewers are more likely to prioritize AI's recommendations. Is AI interviewing reliable? Many people have raised doubts. In an interview with The Wall Street Journal about how AI is changing the recruitment landscape, Alex Huang, a Chinese-American STEM student at the University of Illinois, said, "I have never received a second-round interview invitation after an AI interview." However, his current boss described him as "one of the most outstanding young talents I have encountered in my 30-year career." In addition, it has been reported that Amazon's AI used to score resumes was found to have learned to favor male candidates over female candidates during training. Although HireVue emphasizes that they have removed data points that could cause bias in the AI model, their system algorithms have never been independently reviewed by a third party due to commercial confidentiality. For example, facial expressions commonly used by Asian immigrants may differ from those of white Americans, which could affect the evaluation results. In addition, HireVue's language analysis initially involves converting speech to text, which may introduce bias against people with accents from the southern United States. Even the placement of the camera can become a problem. Will a high angle make the AI think the candidate is too dominant? Will a low angle make the AI think the candidate is timid? Many netizens have sarcastically commented that in this brilliant system, Professor Stephen Hawking would probably only be able to find a job as a grocery store janitor. There are also industry insiders who question whether AI interviews will truly be more efficient. The founder of the AI Now Institute at New York University believes that there is currently insufficient scientific basis for using algorithms to recognize facial expressions and emotions, and it may even lead to more misleading results. Anna Cox, a professor of human-computer interaction at University College London, believes that algorithms will favor those who are good at video interviews, and any dataset will have biases that may exclude those who perform well in actual work. Luke Stark, a researcher at Microsoft's research lab in Montreal, also questions HireVue's ability to assess candidates' personality traits based on their tone and phrases, as even the best AI systems today cannot fully understand human emotions and intentions. However, amidst the opposition, some people believe that the introduction of AI systems actually makes the entire recruitment process more humane. Leena Nair, Chief HR Officer of Unilever, said that AI systems help HR break free from "inertia" and make the hiring process more diverse. Some netizens suggest that companies like HireVue should make their algorithms more transparent to gain trust. The process of "debiasing" should be open-source. In a globally diverse environment, people need to have a better understanding of the human data used to train algorithms. Despite the controversy, HireVue has indeed saved companies like Unilever more than £1 million in recruitment costs in a year. Hilton has reduced the average recruitment cycle from 42 days to 5 days with the help of such AI systems. In the midst of the controversy, HireVue recently received an investment from private equity giant The Carlyle Group. Whether you accept it or not, AI interviews are the trend. Creating a fairer and more just AI is the future that needs to be faced amidst the controversy. Fortunately, the magic of technology is fading away, and humans who hold the sword of knowledge will eventually find the best way to work with AI. Through continuous iteration and optimization in each confrontation, they will overcome the challenges of human-machine integration.

RECENT AI NEWS

RECENT AI TOOLS