Artificial Intelligence Generated Works Cannot Obtain Copyright Protection

2023-08-22

In the battle against artificial intelligence in the creative field, humans have emerged victorious. Last week, a federal judge ruled that works generated by AI are not eligible for copyright protection.

The ruling, made by US District Judge Beryl Howell, stated that copyright law has never "extended" to protect works created by new technological forms without any human guidance. Human authorship is a fundamental requirement.

The idea that AI-generated works do not receive legal protection is good news for those involved in the creative field.

The ruling further stated that US copyright law aims to keep up with the times, but there has always been a consistent belief that human involvement is "at the core of copyright, even if human creativity is guided by new tools or media."

This way of thinking existed even before the emergence of artificial intelligence. Nearly a decade ago, a US district court made a similar ruling in a case involving a monkey's selfie. The court ruled that the selfie could not be protected by copyright because it was not taken by a human.

Judge Howell pointed out that in the case of a camera, for example, the camera does technically generate the image, but it can only do so after a human conceives the image, sets the scene and lighting, adjusts camera settings, and so on. AI does require human involvement in creating prompts, but the actual work is entirely generated by the computer.

This latest ruling is the result of a lawsuit brought by computer scientist Stephen Taylor, who argued that images generated by AI software he created should be eligible for copyright protection.

The US Copyright Office rejected his application for protection, stating that the "link between human thought and creative expression" is a necessary condition for obtaining copyright. In response, Taylor filed a lawsuit challenging the ruling.

While this is a blow to artificial intelligence in the art field, it is worth noting that the Copyright Office has ruled that if humans choose or arrange AI-assisted artistic works in a "sufficiently creative manner," they can be eligible for copyright protection.

RECENT AI NEWS

RECENT AI TOOLS