AI First Time Recognized by Law, Company Fined for Plagiarizing AI-generated Article

2020-01-14

According to a report by China News Agency, the Nanshan District People's Court in Shenzhen recently ruled that articles created by artificial intelligence are protected by copyright, marking an important milestone for AI as a creative force. Over the past five years, Tencent has released content produced by an automated software called Dreamwriter, focusing on business and financial stories. In 2018, a company called Shanghai Yingxun Technology operated a website called "Wangdai Zhi Jia" and copied financial reports generated by Tencent's Dreamwriter. The article included a disclaimer stating that it was "automatically written by Tencent's robot Dreamwriter." However, the court deemed that the article had a certain level of originality and met the legal requirements to be classified as a written work, thus qualifying for copyright protection. Although the defendant has removed the article from their website, they still had to pay a fine of 1500 yuan. In recent years, artificial intelligence has increasingly penetrated various industries, including the realm of creative arts. Google has created an AI-powered tool called AutoDraw, which can recognize what someone is trying to draw and recreate it digitally. There are also mobile applications that can turn your snapshots into hyper-realistic artworks. We have seen AI-assisted popular songs and even short films created by neural networks. Tencent is not the only company using algorithms to write news content. The Associated Press (AP) uses AI in collaboration with Automated Insights for baseball reports and earnings reports. Narrative Science, based in Chicago, offers similar capabilities, focusing on business intelligence or "data storytelling." While this technology works best for data-centric articles and requires manual input of numbers or statistics, the resulting articles are still highly readable. In 2017, the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) magazine published an article suggesting that copyright law could take two potential approaches to computer-generated works, namely "little or no human interaction." It stated that the law could either deny copyright protection for computer-generated works or attribute authorship of such works to the creator of the program. In the case of Tencent, the court seems to have chosen the latter approach. As the creator of the software, Tencent managed to convince the court that it should own the copyright to all content generated by the software. This ruling may set a precedent for similar cases in China, but courts in other countries may not view it in the same way. For example, in the United States, the Copyright Office has strict requirements for "human authorship." They register original works of authorship that are created by natural persons. They state that "copyright law protects intellectual labor that is founded in the creative powers of the mind." It is worth noting that such legalities are not limited to machines. A few years ago, the famous "monkey selfie" case demonstrated this. British photographer David Slater "set up" a scene that eventually led to a monkey taking a selfie with his camera. Slater attempted to claim copyright for the photos but ultimately failed. Interestingly, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) represented the monkey in a lawsuit against Slater, attempting to secure copyright on behalf of the monkey, but PETA also failed. In other instances, the European Patent Office (EPO) recently rejected two applications that claimed machines as creators. The conclusion in the EPO's rejection was quite clear, stating that they did not meet the requirements of the European Patent Convention, which states that "the inventor designated in the application must be a person, not a machine." The potential issue here is that laws around the world are trying to keep up with the impact of AI, but there are signs that the situation is changing. In August of last year, the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) called on experts and the public to determine the impact of AI on intellectual property and, more importantly, "whether new forms of intellectual property protection are needed." It stated, "The USPTO is interested in gathering information on issues related to patenting artificial intelligence inventions to assess whether further examination guidance is needed to promote the reliability and predictability of patenting AI inventions." Clearly, this is an ongoing debate that will continue in the coming years. However, for now, most courts agree that only creative works directly outputted by humans are protected by copyright law.

RECENT AI NEWS

RECENT AI TOOLS