"Can't I Decide What to Do with My Own Face?"

2019-11-05

From a little understanding to whispering, to public criticism, the data privacy issues caused by facial recognition have reached a crossroads where legal intervention is needed as this technology has sunk on a large scale over the years. Yesterday, the hot search term "facial recognition" was no longer just a mouthful or a spectacle, but because someone took legal action. A university professor sued a park that uses facial recognition authentication systems on the grounds of "protecting privacy". The cause of this case, known as the "first facial recognition case in China," is simple: Recently, Guo Bing, an associate professor at Zhejiang Sci-Tech University, received a text message from Hangzhou Wildlife World, informing him that his annual pass for the zoo would not be valid if he did not undergo facial recognition. Guo Bing disagreed with facial recognition and, after unsuccessful negotiations, filed a lawsuit against Hangzhou Fuyang District People's Court on October 28. The local court has now formally accepted the case. The sequence of events is as follows: On April 27, 2019, Guo Bing spent 1360 yuan to purchase an annual pass for Hangzhou Wildlife World. The card is valid for one year and has unlimited entries. Card and fingerprint verification were required upon entry. On October 17, 2019, the park sent him a text message stating that the annual pass system had been upgraded to facial recognition entry, and fingerprint recognition had been canceled. Starting from that day, users who had not registered for facial recognition would not be able to enter the park. After seeing the message, Guo Bing went to the zoo on October 26, 2019, to verify the information. The staff clearly informed him that the system had been upgraded and that facial recognition was now used instead of fingerprint recognition. If he did not register for facial recognition, he would not receive a refund for the annual pass and would not be allowed to enter the zoo. Guo Bing believes that the park's upgraded annual pass system, which uses facial recognition, collects his facial features and other personal biometric information. Such information is considered sensitive personal information, and once leaked, illegally provided, or abused, it can easily endanger the personal safety and property of consumers, including the plaintiff. According to Article 29 of the Consumer Rights Protection Law, the park should collect and use the plaintiff's personal information in accordance with the principles of legality, legitimacy, and necessity, and clearly state the purpose, method, and scope of collecting and using the information with the plaintiff's consent. Moreover, the defendant's collection and use of the plaintiff's personal information should publicly disclose its collection and use rules and must not violate the provisions of laws, regulations, and agreements regarding the collection and use of information. Guo Bing believes that the defendant, without the plaintiff's consent, forcibly collected the plaintiff's personal biometric information by upgrading the annual pass system, which seriously violated relevant regulations and harmed the plaintiff's legitimate rights and interests. The park's official response is interesting because they are quite puzzled. When it comes to "facial recognition," everyone exclaims, "My privacy data has been stolen." But why is no one concerned about fingerprints, phone numbers, and ID card information? After unsuccessful negotiations, Guo Bing filed a lawsuit against Hangzhou Fuyang District People's Court on October 28, 2019. The court has now formally accepted the case. The case has sparked public debate. Xue Jun, Deputy Dean of Peking University Law School, believes that it should be prohibited and refunded. The reason is that individual biometric information, such as faces, genes, irises, fingerprints, palm prints, voiceprints, and gaits, should be prohibited from collection and use due to their high sensitivity. Once leaked, they are almost irreparable. Regarding the refund issue, it should follow the principle of fairness, and the party at fault, in this case, the park, should be responsible for refunding the amount proportionate to the valid period of the pass. Qiu Baochang, Director of the Consumer Rights Legal Affairs Professional Committee of the Beijing Lawyers Association, holds the same opinion. The reason is that the park's change from fingerprint recognition to facial recognition is a change in contract conditions and violates the consumer's right to independent choice. The party that changed the contract, in this case, the park, should bear the liability for breach of contract. Internet users' reactions were not surprising. In addition to supporting the professor, they also brought up the recent controversial campus surveillance project and the campus surveillance incident caused by BrainCo's brain-machine interface headband. In fact, when this technology is finally brought to court, my feelings are mixed. On the one hand, it seems that the public's concern for privacy and their seriousness has come a bit late. If this happened two years ago, when Alipay and WeChat's facial recognition payment had not been introduced, when airport facial recognition gates had not been implemented, when major banks' apps and counters had not integrated facial recognition, when residential areas did not have facial recognition access control at the entrance, and when companies had not switched to facial recognition time clocks... maybe there would still be a slight possibility of saying "no." But now, in a time when you can use facial recognition to pay for a meal at a local restaurant, your so-called "facial rights" are no longer under your control. Let's be honest, have you voluntarily authenticated your facial information at least once when surrounded by facial recognition devices? On the other hand, the reason why all the attention is focused on "facial recognition" is because it is the "scapegoat" among the current applications of new technologies. Many people say that facial and genetic data are unchangeable biological information and the last line of personal security. It sounds serious. But in reality, compared to the misuse of facial information, the consequences of apps using the microphone permissions you granted to "eavesdrop" on your voice information, or the theft, substitution, and sale of consumer information on e-commerce websites, are much more serious. The latter is more common and happens all the time. Otherwise, do you think the personalized recommendations on many music apps would be so accurate? An engineer once revealed, "It's just a rule, nothing serious." At the end of 2018, Amazon's smart speakers were exposed to a major eavesdropping incident, marking the beginning of the "global smart hardware eavesdropping storm." A German user revealed to a local magazine that when he asked Amazon for his personal voice data, he received 1,700 voice recordings of conversations with strangers. An employee of a domestic smart speaker company once revealed that in order to obtain more voice data, smart speakers automatically start recording for a certain period of time. This is not news in the industry. For example, a friend once discovered in the middle of the night when he got up to go to the bathroom that his brand's smart speaker on the bedside table was in recording mode. ... But do these behaviors have anything to do with the technology itself? In fact, these data collection and storage methods, which are not directly related to "artificial intelligence" or "facial recognition," have diverted our attention. Some say that if a password is cracked, you can change it, but once facial data is leaked, it cannot be changed. But the same goes for ID cards. Once identity information is leaked, it cannot be changed either. However, unlike identity information, if ID card numbers and phone numbers are leaked, they can be used by criminals for fraudulent activities. On the other hand, there are very few cases where leaked facial data is directly exploited. The "deepfake" videos that many people mention are currently only used for pranks, and there are no real criminal cases to refer to. According to a security engineer, there have been no large-scale illegal activities directly caused by the leakage of facial recognition data. Although there are some known cases, the overall number of cases directly caused by facial recognition data is small. How should we approach this issue? At a time when someone is willing to use costly legal means to protect their privacy rights, I believe that the ultimate goal of this professor's lawsuit is not to recover the cost of the pass, but to draw attention from the legal community. We must admit a harsh reality: developing artificial intelligence requires a large amount of data, and sacrificing some privacy is inevitable to obtain this data. Three or four years ago, everyone was focused on the development of underlying artificial intelligence technology, and this contradiction was still in its infancy. However, as the technology is gradually being widely promoted and used, the contradiction has been gradually intensified in the awakening of public privacy awareness in China. So, should we give up developing this technology to protect privacy? Or should we sacrifice privacy for technological development? Neither. What we need to do is draw a line between privacy and technological development. We need collective discussions to determine how much public privacy needs to be sacrificed to achieve overall social benefits. The standard for drawing this line is simple: how to obtain more benefits within the acceptable range of privacy loss. For example, if a medical expert tells a cancer patient that the hospital needs some personal body data to better analyze and control the condition, what do you think the chances are that the patient will refuse? In reality, in many scenarios, we are not unwilling to "contribute" some of our data. We are concerned about whether this data will be illegally used. Therefore, the solution lies in addressing the issue of "how to prevent illegal use of data." However, things are often not that simple. A month ago, there was a hot search about someone openly selling "facial data" on an online marketplace, with a quantity of up to 170,000. Interestingly, these data were fully labeled, including facial position information, gender, facial expressions, and attractiveness. Many of the people in these photos had no idea that their faces had been illegally collected. The buyers were developers working on computer vision or facial model training. If we consider public security, the use of facial data can still be further discussed. But can we trust hospitals, shopping malls, schools, and various commercial places with our data? History has shown that once a technology becomes ubiquitous, even if security issues have not been fully resolved, people start to accept it. This means that we need to pay more attention to "whether the companies developing and deploying facial recognition technology and the businesses using this technology are trustworthy" rather than "whether the public will reject or accept facial recognition technology due to privacy issues." So, in this case, do you trust the zoo and the information service provider that provides the system to the zoo?

RECENT AI NEWS

RECENT AI TOOLS